Waverly Hills Sanatorium Lawsuit: A Dispute Over Ownership and Preservation
Waverly Hills Sanatorium, a former tuberculosis treatment hospital in Louisville, Kentucky, has been the subject of a legal battle between its owner, Charlie Mattingly, and the Waverly Hills Historical Society (WHHS), a non-profit organization dedicated to preserving the sanatorium’s history.
The dispute centers on Mattingly’s plans for the property, which include developing it into a commercial enterprise with attractions such as a haunted house and a zip line. The WHHS, on the other hand, wants to preserve the sanatorium as a historical landmark and educational resource.
Allegations of Financial Mismanagement
In 2019, the WHHS filed a lawsuit against Mattingly, alleging that he had mismanaged the sanatorium’s finances and diverted funds for his personal use. The lawsuit also accused Mattingly of neglecting the property, allowing it to fall into disrepair.
Mattingly denied the allegations and countersued the WHHS, claiming that the organization had interfered with his efforts to develop the property.
Settlement Reached
In March 2023, the parties reached a settlement agreement. Under the terms of the agreement, Mattingly will retain ownership of the sanatorium, but he will be required to consult with the WHHS on any plans for its development. The WHHS will also have access to the property for historical research and educational purposes.
The settlement has been met with mixed reactions. Some people are concerned that Mattingly will still be able to develop the property into a commercial enterprise, while others are hopeful that the WHHS will be able to preserve its historical integrity.
The Future of Waverly Hills Sanatorium
The future of Waverly Hills Sanatorium remains uncertain. The settlement agreement gives the WHHS a say in Mattingly’s plans for the property, but it is ultimately up to Mattingly to decide how to develop it.
The WHHS has expressed its commitment to preserving the sanatorium’s history and educational value. The organization plans to continue offering tours of the property and hosting events that educate the public about the history of tuberculosis and the sanatorium’s role in Louisville’s history.
Mattingly has also said that he is committed to preserving the sanatorium’s historic character. He has stated that he does not want to develop the property into a “Disneyland” and that he wants to respect the sanatorium’s past.
It remains to be seen how Mattingly and the WHHS will work together to develop Waverly Hills Sanatorium in a way that respects its history while also ensuring its future viability.
Additional Information
- The Waverly Hills Sanatorium was built in 1926 and treated over 16,000 patients during its time in operation.
- The sanatorium closed in 1961 due to the development of antibiotics, which made tuberculosis treatment more effective and less costly.
- The sanatorium has been featured in numerous paranormal investigations and is considered to be one of the most haunted places in Kentucky.
